Voted Best Summer Day Camp in Napa County 2023
by North Bay Bohemian

Voted Best Virtual Theater in Napa County 2022
by the North Bay Bohemian 

Voted Best Virtual Theater in Napa County 2021 
by the North Bay Bohemian 

Nominated in multiple categories 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023 Nominees for Center of Volunteer & Non Profit Leadership's Annual Heart of Napa Awards for:

• Board Leadership
• Excellence in Leadership
• Achievement in Nonprofit Excellence
• ​Recipient for Youth Volunteer of the Year Award for Sophie Heflebower, 2020

Cafeteria Kids Theater and Napa Valley College 2018 musical production of Mary Poppins won multiple awards at the 35th Arty Awards (PAN-Arts) including:

• Top honor in the youth category winning Outstanding Youth Production
• Outstanding Direction, Youth Production- Aimée Guillot and Olivia Cowell
• Outstanding Musical Direction, Youth Production- Vivian McLaughlin
• Outstanding Set Design, Youth Production- Tanya Orellana